I went in watching a man try to go home and fail repeatedly for reasons that were entirely psychological. Not one obstacle in that story is really about the sea. Every single one is about what happens to a person during a long journey when the destination stops being visible.
I have not been able to stop thinking about it since, and not for the reasons the film critics are writing about.
Here's the thing nobody mentions about the actual story. Odysseus expected to be home in days. It took twenty years.
That gap between expectation and reality is the entire poem. Everything else is decoration. He wasn't lost because he didn't know where Ithaca was. He knew exactly where it was the whole time. He was lost because the distance between him and it kept expanding for reasons he couldn't control, and because the version of himself who left Troy was not the version who would eventually arrive.
Financial independence works the same way and almost nobody says so out loud. The maths is genuinely simple. Spend less than you earn. Invest the difference. Wait. Any twelve-year-old could follow the instructions. The reason most people never get there has nothing to do with not understanding the instructions.
The Sirens are the easy one to spot, which is why they're not the dangerous one
Everyone knows this bit. Creatures whose song was so good that sailors steered into the rocks trying to get closer. Odysseus wanted to hear it, so he had his men tie him to the mast and plug their own ears with wax. He heard the whole thing. He screamed at them to untie him. They didn't, because he'd told them not to, before he heard it.
That's crypto Twitter during a run. That's your cousin's sure thing. That's the trade everyone in your group chat is in and you're not.
What people get wrong is thinking Odysseus beat the Sirens with willpower. He didn't. He beat them by removing his own ability to act while the song was playing. The decision was made in advance by a calmer version of himself and the version who heard the music had no say.
That's the actual lesson and it's less inspiring than the version people usually tell. You are not going to out-discipline a genuinely tempting opportunity in the moment. Nobody does. What you can do is decide what you will and won't buy before anything exciting happens, and then make it slightly difficult to change your mind.
Calypso is the one that gets almost everybody
Seven years. He was on that island for seven years.
This is the part of the story that I find genuinely uncomfortable, because Calypso is not a monster. She's not trying to eat him. There's no battle. She's a goddess who loves him and offers him a comfortable life and, at one point, immortality. All he has to do is stop trying to get home.
He wasn't suffering. He wasn't imprisoned in any way that mattered. He was just somewhere pleasant that wasn't where he was trying to go, and seven years disappeared.
Every Malaysian in their thirties who got a promotion and watched their savings rate stay exactly where it was knows Calypso. The income went up. The lifestyle went up to match. The number in the account did roughly nothing. Nothing bad happened. That's the entire problem.
The Sirens announce themselves. You know when you're being tempted by something stupid. Calypso doesn't feel like temptation at all, she feels like success. A nicer car, a better apartment, holidays you can afford now. Each individual decision is completely reasonable. The problem only becomes visible when you add up the years.
The uncomfortable question isn't whether you're comfortable. It's whether comfortable is where you were trying to end up. Those are not the same thing and confusing them costs people decades.
The Cyclops is the one everyone survives and nobody talks about
Odysseus and his crew get trapped in a cave by a giant who starts eating them. He escapes by getting the giant drunk, blinding him, and hiding under sheep. Classic. Very memorable.
What gets skipped is the cost. He lost men. He lost time. And on the way out, he taunted the giant, who happened to be the son of Poseidon, which is roughly why the next several years went so badly for him. One decision made in a moment of confidence turned a difficult journey into a much longer one.
Odysseus survived it. That's the part worth holding onto. A bad decision does not end the journey. It just makes it longer, and most people who've had one spend more energy on the shame than on the recovery.
And then there's Penelope, who I think is the actual point
Twenty years. Suitors in her house eating her food, telling her he's dead, pressuring her to remarry. She stalls them by weaving a burial shroud and unravelling it every night so it's never finished.
She does nothing dramatic. She doesn't fight anyone. She just refuses to stop doing the boring thing that keeps the situation alive.
Nobody writes about Penelope the way they write about the monsters, and I understand why. There's no scene. There's no set piece. She's just there, for two decades, not giving up, and the whole story only works because of it.
That's the index fund nobody posts about. That's the EPF contribution you stopped checking. That's the gold you bought in 2023 and then forgot about while everyone else was busy panicking about the ringgit.
How far is your Ithaca, actually
I built this because I wanted to know my own number and it annoyed me that I had to open a spreadsheet to find it. Put your real figures in. Nothing is stored anywhere.
Odysseus expected days. Find out what you're actually looking at.
What I keep coming back to
The thing that actually got me about the story is that Odysseus never forgot what Ithaca looked like.
Twenty years, and he could still describe it. The specific island. His actual wife. His son who was an infant when he left. When he was on Calypso's island being offered immortality he turned it down for a rocky bit of land and a woman who might not even still be alive, because he knew precisely what he was aiming at.
Most people can't do that with money. Ask someone what they're building toward and you'll get "financial freedom" or "not having to worry" or "being comfortable." Those are moods. You cannot navigate toward a mood. When something better and closer comes along, and it will, a mood offers no resistance whatsoever.
I don't think the answer is a spreadsheet with a target number, though that helps. I think it's being able to describe the actual life clearly enough that the tempting detour is obviously a detour when it shows up.
Homer wasn't writing about money. He was writing about what happens to people during long difficult efforts, and money is just the long difficult effort most of us happen to be in the middle of. The patterns are the same because the psychology is the same and it hasn't changed in three thousand years, which is either comforting or bleak depending on the day.
Ithaca is still there. That was always the easy part.
Become a subscriber receive the latest updates in your inbox.